Porsche has simply unveiled what is anticipated to turn into its hottest electrical mannequin, the Macan EV. Following within the footsteps of the gas-burning Macan, which is presently the most well-liked Porsche mannequin—over 800,000 have been bought since its introduction nearly a decade in the past—the Macan EV appears destined to take the German model electrical in an entire new means.
Nonetheless, whereas it has the tech, the seems to be, the badge, and the efficiency to permit it to shoot for the highest spot in its class, there may be one established rival which will show to be a thorn in its facet: the virtually an identical in dimension and significantly cheaper Tesla Mannequin Y. The Porsche is marginally greater, it has an even bigger battery pack, and even with out seeing one, we all know it’s going to really feel like a extra luxurious and higher-quality product.
Nonetheless, the Tesla is so good that it could nonetheless steer Macan EV patrons its means. Let’s break it all the way down to see how these comparable however in another way priced sporty electrical crossovers evaluate.
Since Porsche has not introduced any plans to supply a single-motor, rear-wheel drive-only model of the Macan EV with a smaller battery pack, for this text, we are going to solely be wanting on the comparable, big-battery variations of the Tesla Mannequin Y: the Lengthy Vary and the Efficiency.
Vary And Charging
Porsche has solely introduced one battery possibility for the Macan EV: a 100-kWh pack with a usable capability of 95 kWh. There are not any EPA vary numbers but for the U.S. market, however it might go over 300 miles on a single cost (greater than the Taycan).
The extra optimistic European WLTP vary rankings have been made public, nonetheless, and they’re as much as 380 miles for the Macan 4 and 367 miles for the Macan Turbo.
Tesla presents two variations of the Mannequin Y with the bigger 82 kWh (75 kWh usable capability): the Lengthy Vary, which has an EPA vary of 310 miles, and the Efficiency, with 285 miles. Based on the WLTP check cycle utilized in Europe, the Mannequin Y Lengthy Vary can do as much as 331 miles on one cost, whereas the Efficiency can solely hope to go as much as 319 miles.
A pre-production Macan EV was put by the 70 mph vary check and it went over 300 miles.
Evaluating WLTP rankings, the Porsche, with its greater battery, does appear to have the sting, however the real-world outcomes could also be a lot nearer. The Tesla is lighter and extra aerodynamic, so it might stretch its fewer kilowatt hours additional.
The Macan EV is the primary Volkswagen Group car constructed on the brand new PPE devoted EV structure. That title stands for Premium Platform Electrical, and will probably be shared with different group manufacturers like Audi, which is utilizing it to underpin its upcoming electrical Q6 electrical crossover.
The PPE platform, shared with the upcoming Audi Q6 E-Tron and different fashions quickly, has an 800-volt electrical structure that enables for a few of the quickest EV charging within the business. Porsche says the Macan could be juiced at a charge of as much as 270 kW, sufficient to convey the cost from 10 to 80 p.c in 22 minutes or add 60 miles of vary in 4 minutes.
Tesla equips the Mannequin Y with a 400-volt battery pack, so it will want much more amperage than the Porsche to achieve very excessive charging speeds. Nonetheless, even at 400 volts, the Mannequin Y remains to be in a position to cost at as much as 210 kW, which may add as much as 200 miles of vary in simply quarter-hour. It’s not fairly as quick as an 800-volt automobile just like the Macan EV, however it’s not far off.
Dimensions And Practicality
Though the Porsche Macan EV shouldn’t be pitched as a direct Tesla Mannequin Y rival, its dimensions are nearly an identical.
The Macan measures 4,784 mm (188.34 inches) in size; it rides on a 2,893 mm (113.9-inch) wheelbase, and its complete width, together with mirrors, is 2,152 mm (84.7 inches). Evaluate that to the Mannequin Y’s 4,751 mm (187-inch) complete size, its 2,890 mm (113.8-inch) wheelbase, and its width with mirrors of two,129 mm (83.8 inches), and it will nearly seem as if Porsche was making an attempt to emulate its dimensions.
Each autos are nearly an identical by way of top too, with the Macan being 2 mm decrease than the Mannequin Y, for a complete top of 1,622 mm. The Porsche has barely higher floor clearance, and it may be adjusted in autos geared up with the non-compulsory air suspension.
Nonetheless, though they’ve an nearly an identical footprint and really comparable dimensions, the Porsche is significantly heavier than the Tesla. The producer lists the bottom Macan 4 as weighing 5,136 kilos, whereas neither of the 2 Mannequin Y variations exceeds the 2-ton mark, in order that they’re each underneath 4,400 kilos.
On the subject of practicality, the 2 autos appear evenly matched with comparable ranges of cargo room. Each autos have a frunk, however the Tesla can accommodate a bigger load quantity general, with 4.1 cubic ft (117 liters) within the entrance and a really spectacular 30.2 cubic ft (854 liters) within the rear. In case you fold down the rear seats, the area expands to 72.1 cubic ft (2,041 liters), which is unmatched within the section.
The Macan EV’s frunk is smaller, with a capability of three cubic ft (84 liters), as is its 19-cubic-foot (540-liter) trunk. It due to this fact can’t match the Tesla’s practicality, particularly because the Mannequin Y is accessible as a seven-seater, though solely youngsters will realistically slot in its third row.
Efficiency And Trim Ranges
Porsche solely presents the Macan EV with an all-wheel drive and two-motor configuration. The bottom Macan 4 has a mixed output from its two motors of 402 horsepower and 479 pound-feet of torque. It hits 62 mph (100 km/h) from a standstill in 5.2 seconds, and it’ll hold accelerating to 137 mph. The highest-tier Macan Turbo pushes the numbers to 630 horsepower and a mountain-moving 833 pound-feet of torque, good for naught to 62 mph time of three.3 seconds and a prime velocity of 161 mph.
These numbers are marginally higher than the Mannequin Y, which in Lengthy Vary guise has a dual-motor setup with 384 horsepower and 376 pound-feet of torque that may push it to 60 mph in a claimed 4.8 seconds, though impartial checks have proven it’s even faster.
The Mannequin Y Efficiency bumps the output to 456 horsepower and 497 pound-feet of torque, which may push the car to 60 mph in a claimed 3.5 seconds.
The highest velocity for the Tesla Mannequin Y is 135 mph for the Lengthy Vary and 155 mph for the Efficiency.
Needless to say we’re evaluating 0 to 60 and 0 to 62 mph instances right here since Porsche has solely launched dash instances to 100 km/h, however US-specific numbers will likely be introduced because the car will get nearer to its official American market debut within the second half of 2024.
What is clear when evaluating the numbers is that the Mannequin Y presents distinctive bang for the buck, with the Lengthy Vary model surpassing the Macan 4 for acceleration and nearly matching its prime velocity. The Mannequin Y Efficiency can’t fairly match the Macan Turbo’s acceleration time (which we’ve got a hunch will likely be even faster than claimed with sticky tires and in the proper situations), however it’s not far off.
We’ve not had an opportunity to drive the Macan EV but, however given Porsche’s repute, our expectations are very excessive. Nonetheless, the Mannequin Y is understood for its agile dealing with and the truth that it hides its weight and dimension very nicely. Head-to-head observe checks of those two autos would possibly yield stunning outcomes, and the Tesla ought to nonetheless be capable of maintain its personal round a observe, each by way of lap instances and having enjoyable behind the wheel.
Tech And Particular Options
Porsche is pitching the Macan EV as a barely extra luxurious and upmarket providing in comparison with the Tesla Mannequin Y. That is mirrored not solely within the beginning worth but in addition in a few of the choices you possibly can specify.
The Macan is accessible with air suspension, a luxurious automobile characteristic that improves consolation and permits for a variable trip top. It permits the automobile to decrease itself for improved effectivity, in addition to maximize its floor clearance when going off-road.
One other characteristic you count on to see on bigger and extra luxurious automobiles is rear-wheel steering, which is a $2,040 possibility for the Macan EV and a primary for the Macan nameplate. The Macan EV’s rear wheels have a most steering angle of 5 levels, they usually cut back its turning circle radius from 39.6 ft to 36.4 ft and assist the car really feel extra maneuverable at decrease speeds. Rear-wheel steering additionally helps the automobile preserve its stability by higher-speed corners when the rear wheels are handing over the identical course because the fronts.
You too can get the Macan EV with as much as three screens within the entrance, together with a curved show that serves as a digital gauge cluster. The Mannequin Y solely has the middle infotainment display, and you’ll’t specify any extra screens. An augmented actuality head-up show can also be obtainable, which guarantees to overlay navigation and different bits of knowledge proper onto the windscreen.
The Mannequin Y has neither of those options, however it does have its celebration methods. The massive one is Autopilot (and the likelihood to choose into the Full Self-Driving Beta program, which brings much more superior autonomous driving options), in addition to cameras throughout the car that can be utilized each as a touch cam whilst you’re driving and to maintain a lookout across the car whereas parked (the latter is named Sentry Mode, and it even shows a Hal 9000esque glowing crimson dot on the display to discourage anyone from tampering with the car).
Some extra uncommon Mannequin Y options embody Canine Mode, Theater Mode, Caraoke, Arcade, and Toybox. A couple of of these options are extra enjoyable than helpful, however they assist set the Tesla aside from different autos.
Pricing
Porsche needs $80,450 (vacation spot cost included) for a Macan 4, whereas the top-of-the-range Macan Turbo begins at $106,950. With the choices that almost all patrons will specify, the Macan 4 can shortly move the $100,000 mark, whereas the Turbo’s worth can go north of $130,000 for those who begin piling on the choices—it could actually go as excessive as $160,000. Not like the Tesla, the Macan doesn’t qualify for any tax incentives except it’s leased.
The Tesla Mannequin Y Lengthy Vary begins at a way more cheap $48,990. In case you don’t need to have it in the usual Stealth Gray paint, you’ll have to pay $1,000 or $2,000 extra, relying on which non-compulsory end you go for. The non-compulsory 20-inch Induction wheels add one other $2,000, and the tow hitch is one other $1,000, the identical because the cool-looking white inside.
In order for you the seven-seater, that will likely be one other $3,000, whereas Full Self-Driving functionality is a whopping $12,000. A totally-spec’d Mannequin Y Lengthy Vary will value simply shy of $70,000. Lots of the similar choices (besides the wheels, that are normal Überturbine 21s, and the third row of seats) can be found on the Mannequin Y Efficiency. It begins at $52,490, so with all of the packing containers checked, a fully-specced Mannequin Y Efficiency will value only a bit over $70,000.
That’s fairly an enormous worth hole, and that is earlier than you issue within the $7,500 federal tax credit score that the Tesla is eligible for in 2024. The Tesla’s affordability and mix of options could steer some Macan EV patrons its means.
Would you think about one over the opposite? Tell us within the feedback.