Minivans: the cargo pants of vehicles. Beloved and bemoaned alike for his or her functionality-above-all-else packaging, a minivan is the most effective device for many family-related jobs. Should you’re studying this, we’re most likely preaching to the choir, however even the transformed might not be conscious of the present state of the phase. Spoiler alert: It is bleak. Should you thought the Kia Carnival was going to immediate a resurgence of quick noses and sliding doorways, properly, put together to be disenchanted.
Usually, we might simply checklist our favorites in alphabetical order, however given the variety of minivans at the moment on sale and the truth that there’s barely room out there for good minivans, not to mention mediocre ones, we’re merely itemizing all of them together with their respective professionals and cons. Realistically, there aren’t any true duds on this group, however relying in your priorities and what you are prepared to commerce off (say, accepting a hybrid powertrain if gas financial system is of prime significance), you might be much more restricted in your decisions to determine the most effective minivan to purchase in 2024. To get a really feel for what we search for in a great new minivan, try our comparability check between the Chrysler Pacifica and Toyota Sienna. Whereas there, you may additionally see which of the contenders we imagine is the most effective hybrid minivan.
open fullscreen
shut fullscreen
Chrysler Pacifica (and Pacifica Hybrid)
Why it stands out: Distinctive plug-in hybrid; versatile Stow ‘n Go seats; nice leisure options; beauty.
What could possibly be higher: No cheaper base trim; prime trims and Hybrid are actually costly; less-comfy second-row Stow ‘n Go seats.
Learn our full Chrysler Pacifica Assessment
Chrysler has been constructing minivans because the notion was first conceived, and whereas ChryCo cannot technically be credited with inventing the idea, it was definitely chargeable for endearing it to American automotive patrons. The Pacifica itself is now seven years outdated, which is superior by vehicular getting old requirements, nevertheless it stays aggressive because of a top-notch inside (supplied you are prepared to pay for all of the bells and whistles) and an out there plug-in hybrid system that gives 32 miles of electric-only vary. That is not solely a phase unique, however fairly strong by standard PHEV metrics.
The Pacifica’s inside is fairly enticing and well-appointed. It is not fairly as fairly because the Sienna or Carnival inside, nevertheless it’s a strong effort. It additionally comes filled with the phase’s greatest tech. Chrysler’s Uconnect infotainment is superb as at all times and integrates with the rear seats to offer Bluetooth connections and charging factors. There’s additionally a full manufacturing unit rear-seat leisure possibility if Uconnect and a few tablets cannot get the job performed.
Its normal 3.6-liter V6 makes 287 horsepower and 262 pound-feet of torque; the PHEV makes rather less energy (simply 260 hp), however the instantaneous torque from its electrical motors make it really feel a lot faster, plus it could function on battery energy alone for brief errands and commutes. Steering and dealing with are each affordable, however remember that the PHEV weighs practically 600 kilos greater than the usual V6; regulate your stopping distance accordingly. Plus, that hybrid is pricey. Count on to pay north of $50,000 simply to get out the door except incentives return in an enormous method.
The largest knock in opposition to the Pacifica is that its predicted reliability stays hit-or-miss. In a crowd that features Honda and Toyota, that is one thing to think about. It is also price noting a considerably up to date Pacifica is rumored for 2025.
open fullscreen
shut fullscreen
Honda Odyssey
Why it stands out: ‘Magic’ center row nice for fogeys with small children; plush journey; Honda reliability status.
What could possibly be higher: No cheaper base mannequin; dreary to drive even for a minivan; no hybrid or AWD.
Learn our full Honda Odyssey Assessment
We confer with the Odyssey as “the final word piece of parenting gear,” tying properly into our cargo pants theme above. The Odyssey might be the least objectively attention-grabbing mannequin on this combine, however since when has that mattered? Its solely true deficit is its middling gas financial system, which in Honda’s case is not offset by the provision of a hybrid powertrain. Sadly, the day of the Odyssey driving like an Accord are lengthy gone; it is the least dynamically partaking of the bunch nevertheless it’s nonetheless quiet and comfy, as a street journey machine needs to be.
The massive factor Honda has going for it’s its “Magic Slide” second-row seats. We go into these in depth on this Odyssey Driveway Check, together with their glorious means to accommodate toddler automotive seats, however in brief, it is a sensible thought and properly suited to folks of younger youngsters (though the Carnival’s personal distinctive eight-passenger configuration comes shut). Older children would most likely recognize the far-sliding captain’s chairs within the seven-passenger Carnival and Sienna that present much more sprawl-out house (the Odyssey’s restricted fore-aft adjustment additionally leads to a smaller hole between the seat and pillar for third-row entry). Must you be prioritizing cargo versatility, the most effective guess is unequivocally the non-hybrid Pacifica’s fold-away Stow ‘N Go seats.
Its inside tech is a bit on the ho-hum aspect, nevertheless it’s largely practical. We usually choose the interfaces of the Carnival and Pacifica, plus the Sienna’s out there widescreen system. Honda was the primary to carry an in-cabin vacuum again to the phase, and that has since been copied by Toyota and Chrysler. What, Kia children do not go away crumbs?
open fullscreen
shut fullscreen
Kia Carnival
Why it stands out: Trendy; nice tech; a number of trick second-row seat choices.
What could possibly be higher: No hybrid or all-wheel-drive possibility; comparatively small third row.
Learn our full Kia Carnival Assessment
Within the minivan world, not wanting like a minivan is mostly thought of an enchancment (see: pants that aren’t cargo). By that normal, the Kia Carnival is a supermodel. Nevertheless, there are these amongst us right here at Autoblog who suppose it tries a bit too onerous. Magnificence is within the eye of the beholder, after all, however there is no denying the truth that Kia’s entry gives a reasonably uncommon aesthetic for the sliding-row phase.
Like all minivans, an enormous differentiator is the second-row idea, however the Carnival stands out a bit additional by providing two totally different novel ideas. Eight-passenger fashions have a novel, far-sliding center seat that gives myriad distinctive seating preparations, whereas the reclining “VIP Lounge” seats slide extra-far and have pop-out leg restraints (to be truthful, Toyota gives one thing related). The third row is a barely cramped in comparison with the others, however that is very relative. Kia’s tech can be among the many strongest within the mainstream biz, so you may get a great infotainment system with easy-to-use controls.
On the street, the Carnival is a nice driving companion providing V6 energy typical for the phase (290 horsepower and 262 pound-feet of torque). It is not fairly as enjoyable to maneuver because the Sienna, nevertheless it’s on the athletic finish of what’s admittedly a reasonably sedentary phase. The shortage of all-wheel drive or a hybrid powertrain is a little bit of a downer.
We’re anticipating a newly refreshed Kia Carnival to hit dealerships quickly with some significant updates. There’s additionally rumors of a hybrid powertrain possibility that we hope are true.
open fullscreen
shut fullscreen
Toyota Sienna
Why it stands out: Monumental gas financial system benefit; big-kid-friendly second-row; above-average dealing with; inside storage
What could possibly be higher: Not as highly effective as different minivans; much less superior infotainment; low cost inside supplies on decrease trims
Learn our full Toyota Sienna Assessment
Toyota has determined to go all-in on the hybrid minivan system, making it the unique powertrain for what’s in any other case a fairly standard minivan providing.
The Sienna’s cabin is a story of two committees. The cheaper trims look the half, however well-optioned cabins present fairly properly. That is nice if you wish to promote fancier minivans however not so nice for these amongst us who aren’t ready to fork over that sort of money. The Sienna gives a alternative of two inside configurations. The eight-passenger mannequin might be higher suited to folks with smaller children because it comes with a detachable second-row center seat that you could affix a baby seat to whereas protecting the outboard seats open (the Pacifica gives one thing related). The seven-passenger setup discovered on higher trim ranges options the brand new “Tremendous Lengthy Slide” second-row captain’s chairs, which slide additional than its rivals by a substantial quantity. Slid to the rear, they supply sufficient legroom for NBA forwards to relax and loosen up.
Sienna is down on energy with out the usual V6 that each different mannequin on this phase gives. That stated, 245 horsepower is nothing to sneeze at, particularly in a household hauler that returns 36 mpg mixed with front-wheel drive 35 mpg mixed with AWD. Oh, do we have now your consideration now? That could be a huge benefit for this Toyota because it might prevent as a lot as $1,000 per yr in fuel financial savings relative the V6-powered vans. And it will get higher. What the Sienna lacks in outright energy it makes up for in maneuverability. Yeah, the Toyota is the handler of the phase. What a world, eh?
Associated video: