For years now, the Tesla Mannequin Y has been the most well-liked electrical automotive available on the market, particularly within the West. It hit the fitting steadiness of vary, cost speeds, value and practicality. However plenty of glorious rivals from legacy automakers have entered the market lately. And plenty of of those automobiles just like the Hyundai Ioniq 5 now exceed the Mannequin Y’s capabilities in additional methods than one.
We’ve heard from a number of reviewers who now imagine the Ioniq 5 compares very favorably in opposition to the Mannequin Y. Kurt from the YouTube channel EatSleepDrive counts himself amongst this group. On this video, he explains why in his view, the Ioniq 5 is the electrical crossover you should purchase.
How A lot Will Every Automobile Set You Again?
The Ioniq 5 SE AWD begins at $50,745. The Mannequin Y is barely extra inexpensive with an MSRP of $48,000 for an AWD mannequin. Nonetheless, you’re very prone to get a promotional provide from Hyundai or your native seller that may deliver that value down by a number of thousand {dollars}.
He will get the subjective comparisons out of the best way first. Kurt just isn’t loopy concerning the Mannequin Y’s design. “The primary and most blatant distinction evaluating this to the Mannequin Y is that this doesn’t appear to be a frog.” Whereas many love the clear traces of Tesla’s autos, not everybody does. Remember that a entrance facelift is predicted for the Mannequin Y subsequent 12 months, regardless of Elon Musk’s makes an attempt to cover that info from patrons. So when you favor the look of the present Mannequin 3, then it could be finest so that you can maintain off for the refresh.
However there’s no denying that Tesla’s crossover has turn into so frequent that it blends proper in with a sea of F-150s and Toyota Corollas. By comparability, the Ioniq 5 is “way more trendy, and on the identical time retro, the designers actually killed it with this automotive.”
22 Pictures
On to extra sensible issues, the car is surprisingly roomy, with a a lot bigger passenger area than you would possibly anticipate wanting from the skin. Whereas the small-sized frunk is disappointing, the Ioniq 5 makes up for it with ample storage within the hatch space. With the rear seats down, there’s loads of room for him to lug his massive bike round.
On the vary facet of the equation, the Ioniq 5 sports activities a 77.4 kWh battery that gives a good 260-mile vary with all-wheel drive (AWD) and 303 miles with rear-wheel drive (RWD). However the Mannequin Y’s 85 kWh pack is EPA-rated for 308 miles with AWD and 320 in RWD configurations.
In vary testing, he drove 200 miles in average climate for a mean of three.6 miles/kWh. He ended his vary check with 24% of battery remaining and an estimated 58 miles remaining for the cost. This put the Ioniq 5 proper on par with the acknowledged vary, which has not all the time been the case in his testing, together with with Tesla merchandise.
27 Pictures
He additionally finds the construct high quality of the Mannequin Y to be subpar in comparison with the Hyundai. Whereas Tesla has improved enormously on this entrance through the years, in his expertise “they’re simply not that properly screwed collectively.” He likens the Ioniq 5 construct high quality to Honda or Toyota.
Kurt appreciates the existence of bodily buttons for a lot of frequent options. However the infotainment of the Ioniq 5 remains to be missing in some areas with many necessary features buried in sub-menus. The truth that the 2024 mannequin is lacking USB-C ports and wi-fi Apple Carplay / Android Auto are nonetheless baffling decisions.
One other space the place he feels the Ioniq 5 excels over the Tesla Mannequin Y is the experience high quality. Whereas the Mannequin Y suspension just isn’t horrible, he finds the Ioniq 5 extra snug in each single street situation. It additionally handles properly and is enjoyable to drive on winding mountain roads. “This isn’t meant to be a sports activities automotive by any means. Nevertheless it does have some sporty driving qualities to it. If something, driving this automotive has made me very excited to drive the Ioniq 5 N.”
After all, shopping for a brand new automotive is an especially private resolution, and never everybody will worth the identical options or type. So when you needed to buy a brand new automotive right now, would you contemplate a Tesla Mannequin Y or a Hyundai Ioniq 5? Tell us your ideas within the feedback under.