BHP has unveiled plans to switch its fleet of diesel vans with electrical vans, in a staged transition that won’t solely cut back the corporate’s scope 1 emissions but in addition present large financial savings on operational prices.
“Annually our Australian operations use roughly 1,500 mega litres of diesel in over 1,000 items of kit,” stated vp of planning and technical minerals Australia Anna Wiley.
“Over half of that is utilized in our truck fleets. Electrification is the popular pathway to get rid of this diesel. A part of the explanation for that is vitality effectivity.”
BHP says the way forward for large vans is electrical, not hydrogen
Wiley went on to elucidate the massive variations in vitality effectivity between diesel, hydrogen and electrical vans (proven within the desk on the precise within the picture under).
“The primary row represents the gas motion from supply to the tools. Utilizing hydrogen for instance, you’ll be able to see that the best losses at this section are on account of technology storage and transmission in comparison with minimal losses in electrical energy technology and transmission.
“As soon as on board, the gas must be transferred into vitality. In each in the present day’s diesel electrical expertise and in a hydrogen system, the gas is used to generate electrical energy to drive the electrical wheel motors which has extra losses.
“Placing this collectively within the backside row, we will see that round 80% of general effectivity from electrified pathway in comparison with lower than half of this for hydrogen.”
With “fuel-to-wheel” vitality effectivity losses of 70% for each diesel and hydrogen in comparison with simply 20% for electrical, changing mining truck fleets to electrical is a no brainer.
However the gas value financial savings are even increased than BHP’s evaluation suggests. Wiley’s comparability begins with the hydrogen gas already created. There are additionally large losses concerned in creating hydrogen, in line with vitality skilled Saul Griffith.
“It seems the absolute best case, when you have the proper machine you’re solely going to get somewhat greater than 70% of the vitality you made together with your photo voltaic cell transformed into hydrogen” says Griffith.
6/8
Why hydrogen shouldn’t be a good suggestion. (Half 2) #ElectrifyEverything pic.twitter.com/Cday5tE614
— Daniel Bleakley (@DanielBleakley) February 13, 2022
This implies if BHP’s evaluation is taken from the vitality supply, i.e. photo voltaic or wind energy, the effectivity of the hydrogen system would drop farther from 30% to simply 21% with trivial losses within the all-electric system.
Which means virtually 80% of the unique renewable vitality generated for the hydrogen system can be misplaced by the point it received to transferring the wheels of the truck. Which implies 4-5 occasions extra wind and photo voltaic that must be created to journey the identical distance as an electrical truck and 4-5 occasions extra value.
Electrified mining fleet “extra economical” than diesel and hydrogen
Even with out the pre-fuel comparability, BHP has made up its thoughts on the drivetrain debate
“Our view that an electrified mining fleet is extra economical and extra achievable than the choice gas sources,” stated Anna Wiley.
“Changing diesel requires us to develop an entire operational ecosystem to encompass the fleet and each a part of the mine will likely be touched by this alteration.
“There are nonetheless a variety of unknowns in our future idea of operations, that we have to contemplate. How we plan our mines, how we cost our tools, how we handle energy demand and the talents we’ll want as a part of this transition.
BHP says it’s going to collaborate with tools producers to speed up the event of electrified mine websites. BHP will trial tools on web site because it turns into obtainable.
“I visited the Tucson proving grounds and witnessed each Caterpillar and Komatsu prototypes in operation in battery mode, which was actually thrilling to see.” stated Wiley.
BHP says it’s going to have its first battery electrical haul truck for trialling in 2024.
![BHP operational decarbonisation](https://b2232832.smushcdn.com/2232832/wp-content/uploads/2023/06/BHP-Electrification_04.jpg?lossy=1&strip=0&webp=1)
“As a part of this ecosystem we might want to contemplate how our vans will cost. The precise design will rely upon the mine itself however we anticipate having each static and dynamic charging in place.”
“For dynamic charging, typical trolly charging is obtainable in the present day nonetheless implementation is tough as a result of because the areas we mine change, the infrastructure must be moved.
“We’re supporting one of many Cost On Innovation Problem individuals Bluvein, who’re growing aspect mount dynamic charging programs to enhance each mobility and price effectiveness.” stated Wiley.
The Pushed not too long ago wrote a narrative about Bluvein, an Australian firm, which has developed a dynamic charging system that can assist mine websites cost electrical tools whereas in operation.
![Bluvein Dynamic Charging for mining vehicles](https://b2232832.smushcdn.com/2232832/wp-content/uploads/2023/05/BlueVein_08.jpg?lossy=1&strip=0&webp=1)
On working prices, BHP says electrical wins
“Our preliminary modeling suggests the associated fee [of electric] would be the similar or much less to function in comparison with diesel,” stated Wiley.
“As we transition from diesel to electrical energy, we’ll spend much less on carbon publicity, however we might want to spend extra on electrical energy. Nonetheless we count on the associated fee will likely be much less general given the effectivity of the battery electrical vans and the anticipated vitality value differential.”
“We additionally count on to see general financial savings in truck upkeep as and not using a diesel engine or mechanical drive chain, there are considerably fewer components making the vans easy to keep up.”
BHP’s modelling reveals that battery charging time will be the largest value on the electrical aspect, one thing that dynamic charging can cut back considerably.
![BHP truck savings](https://b2232832.smushcdn.com/2232832/wp-content/uploads/2023/06/BHP-Electrification_05.jpg?lossy=1&strip=0&webp=1)
With battery expertise growing quickly, it’s no surprise the mining trade desires to get in on the huge prices financial savings that include going all-electric.
For more information on the issues going through hydrogen autos, take a look at our story The insanity of Large Auto’s push for hydrogen-powered automobiles
![Daniel Bleakley Profile Picture](https://b2232832.smushcdn.com/2232832/wp-content/uploads/2023/01/1667258499442.jpeg?size=100x100&lossy=1&strip=0&webp=1)
Daniel Bleakley is a clear expertise researcher and advocate with a background in engineering and enterprise. He has a robust curiosity in electrical autos, renewable vitality, manufacturing and public coverage.